Specific SE Issues
Miscellaneous Income From an Occasional Act or Transaction
Income from an occasional act or transaction, absent proof of efforts to continue those acts or transactions on a regular basis, isn't income from self-employment subject to the SE tax. (Rev Rul 58-112, 1958-1 CB 323; Rev Rul 55-431, 1955-2 CB 312; Rev Rul 55-258, 1955-1 CB 433) Regularity of activity, frequency of transactions, and the production of income are key elements in determining whether an activity will be considered a trade or business for SE tax purposes. Income from an occasional act or transaction, without proof of efforts to continue on a regular basis, may not be income from self-employment. In Langford, TC Memo 1988-300, an assistant professor who co-authored a textbook without any obligation to work on later revisions was found not to have trade or business income from the activity. Even though the professor did ultimately revise the book, he was not subject to SE tax.
Notary Public
The fees for the services of a notary public are exempt from the self-employment tax. However, the taxpayer has to prove the income came from notary public services. Merely having a notary seal isn't enough; the taxpayer must produce records of his or her notary public business or other evidence to show he or she isn't subject to the self-employment tax.
Non-Resident Aliens and SE Tax
Non-resident aliens don’t pay self-employment tax. Residents of the Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico, Guam, or American Samoa, however, are subject to the tax. Non-resident and resident aliens employed in the U.S. by an international organization, a foreign government, or a wholly owned instrumentality of a foreign government are not subject to SE tax. See also Chapter 6.3.
Executors and Administrators (Fiduciaries)
A person who administers the estate of a deceased person (i.e., the fiduciary) is subject to SE tax if: (a) the person is a professional fiduciary; or (b) the person is a nonprofessional fiduciary who manages an estate that includes an active trade or business. Nonprofessional fiduciaries are generally not treated as receiving income from a trade or business unless all of the following are met:
-
There is a trade or business among the assets of the estate.
-
The fiduciary actively participates in the operation of this trade or business.
-
The fees of the fiduciary are related to the operation of the trade or business.
Example – Nonprofessional Executor - Taxpayer, a nonprofessional fiduciary, is co-executor of an estate that includes a trade or business and is totally unfamiliar with the operation of the business and leaves the management of the business entirely in the hands of his co-executor. The fees received by the taxpayer aren't earnings from self-employment. (Rev Rul 58-5, 1958-1 CB 322)
-
Example – Managing a Business - A nonprofessional fiduciary receives a fee of $10,000 for acting as executor of an estate. The estate includes a business that the taxpayer manages during the period of administration. Under local law, an executor is entitled to a commission based on a percentage of the value of the assets. Based on the statutory allowance, the taxpayer would have been entitled to a commission of $7,500. However, the probate court allowed, and the taxpayer was paid, a commission of $10,000.
-
Since the statutory commission of $7,500 was attributable to the normal fiduciary duties, it isn't treated as income from a trade or business. The remaining $2,500 is treated as attributable to the operation of the estate's business and thus treated as self-employment income. (Rev Rul 58-5, 1958-1 CB 322)
Example – Conservator Non-business Assets - A surviving spouse, on the death of her husband, was appointed successor conservator of the estate of a friend who was unable to manage her financial affairs. Previously, the surviving spouse’s husband was the conservator. The estate consists solely of a residence occupied by the friend and income producing stocks, bonds, and depository cash accounts. IRS privately ruled that since the services provided by the surviving spouse as conservator didn't relate to any trade or business of the estate, a monthly allowance paid to the taxpayer-conservator wasn't self-employment income. (IRS Letter Ruling 8928030)
-
Example – Executor and Beneficiary - A surviving spouse who operated a community property oil and gas lease as executrix of her husband's estate wasn't liable for self-employment tax on any part of the income from the lease, since she was the sole beneficiary of the estate. Beneficiaries don't realize self-employment income on business carried on by the estate. (Huval, Louisa, (1985) TC Memo 1985-568, PH TCM ¶85568, 50 CCH TCM 1452)
-
Fiduciary of an Estate on an Isolated Basis
Those who serve in the capacity of fiduciary of an estate on an isolated basis (e.g., a friend or relative of the decedent) are not generally subject to SE tax on the fees they receive for their services.
Commissions Allowed by the Probate Court
Commissions allowed by the probate court under local law aren't considered self-employment earnings, but any excess is, on the ground that it represents a special payment for operating the business. (Rev Rul 58-5, 1958-1 CB 322)
Limited Partners
A limited partner’s share of partnership income is not subject to SE tax. IRS proposed regs define who are considered limited partners. The regs apply to all entities classified as partnerships for Federal tax purposes. Generally, an individual partner is treated as a limited partner unless he/she:
-
Has personal liability as a partner for debts of the partnership or claims against it
-
Has authority to contract on the partnership’s behalf under the law which the partnership is recognized; or
-
Participates in the partnership’s trade or business for more than 500 hours during the tax year. If the partnership involved is a service partnership, anyone who provides more than de minimis amount of service isn’t a limited partner. A 2023 Tax Court case (Soroban Capital Partners, LP, et al., v. Comm. 161 T.C. 12) emphasizes that determining whether a partner is really a limited partner or one in name only hinges on looking at the facts and isn’t dependent on titling the partner as a limited partner. The upshot is that to qualify for the exception to the SE tax, the earnings allocated to the partner need to be of an investment nature.
Newspaper Vendors
The income newspaper vendors receive for selling newspapers directly to customers for a profit is not SE income if the vendor is under age 18; for those age 18 and over, it is SE income.
Conservation Reserve Program Payments
Excluded from self-employment income are any Conservation Reserve Program payments made to individuals who are receiving Social Security retirement or disability payments.
Corporate Payments
Fees received for performances of services as a director of a corporation, including director meeting attendance, are SE income. A shareholder’s portion of an S corporation’s taxable income is not SE income.
Partners
If a taxpayer is a member of a partnership that carries on a trade or business, his/her distributive share of the partnership’s income is SE income. Guaranteed payments from the partnership should be included in net earnings from self-employment (in addition to the pass-through income for the year, if the partner is a general partner).
Religious Exemptions
Ministers, Christian Science practitioners, and members of religious orders who haven’t taken a vow of poverty may get an exemption from self-employment tax on their earnings if certain requirements are met. To get the exemption, Form 4361 must be filed.
Spouses May Elect Out of Partnership Rules
A husband and wife who file a joint return may elect out of the partnership rules. Thus, a joint venture between them is not treated as a partnership for tax purposes. (Code Sec. 761(f); Code Sec. 1402(a)(17)) When this election is made, each spouse then files a Schedule C with their portion of the business’ income and expenses, and each would be subject to SE tax. For more detail see Chapter 3.00.
SE Tax for Termination Payments of Former Insurance Salespeople
The law provides that net earnings from self-employment don’t include any amounts received from an insurance company for services performed by an individual as an insurance salesperson for the company if:
-
The amount is received after the individual’s agreement to perform services for the company ends;
-
The person performs no services for the company after the agreement terminates and before the end of the tax year,
-
A condition of the payments is that the salesperson does not compete with the company for at least one year after the end of the agreement, and
-
The amount of the payment depends primarily on:
-
Policies sold by (or credited to the account of) the salesperson during the last year of the agreement, and/or
-
The extent to which the policies remain in force for some period after the agreement ends.
-
The amount of payment can’t depend on the length of service or overall earnings from services performed for the company. However, eligibility for payment can depend on length of service and/or overall earnings.
Agricultural Co-Op Payments to Retired Farmers
Although retired from daily farming activities, taxpayers who are still contractually obligated to supply an agricultural commodity to the agricultural cooperative of which they remain members are in a trade or business of producing, marketing, processing and selling the commodity. The “value added” payments received from the co-op are subject to self-employment tax (Richard J. Bot, CA 8, 12/22/2003 92 AFTR 2d 2003-7385).
Rents Paid in Crop Shares
Rents Paid in Crop Shares - are not subject to SE tax unless paid under an arrangement where the landowner (or tenant) materially participates in crop production or controls and directs the farming operation and pays the farmer at a fixed rate as his employee (Reg § 1.1402(a)-4(b)).
Real Estate Rental Income
Rent from real estate and personal property leased with that real estate is not SE income if no services are provided with the rental. Rents received from a hotel or motel are considered SE income because services (e.g., maid service) are generally provided for the occupants. If substantial services are provided, the income is subject to SE tax. “Substantial” means that part of the rent is actually payment for services. For example, hotels, boarding houses, apartments which furnish hotel services, tourist homes or storage garages. (Reg 1.1402(a)-4(c)(2)) See additional discussion of this topic at page 03.17.06.
Trailer Park Owner
Rev Rule 83-139, CB 1983-2 150 - Monthly income of a trailer park owner who provided insubstantial services for tenants was not subject to SE tax. Provided were lots, a laundry facility, city sewer, and roadway to park. Owner cleaned and maintained premises daily and furnished hot water in the laundry. However, the ruling points out that an owner who provides additional services like a recreation hall, card area, pool room, kitchen, auditorium, stage and library would be subject to SE tax on income.
Fishing Crew Member
(Anderson, TC) - In a case of first impression, the Tax Court held that a member of a fishing boat crew was self-employed because he was compensated solely from the proceeds of the sale of the boat's catch, even though operating expenses were subtracted from the proceeds before the crew's compensation was determined.
The taxpayer argued that the subtraction of the owner's expenses causes him to be classified as an employee due to the requirement in Reg. §31.3121(b)(20)-1(a) that a self-employed crew member's compensation must depend "solely" on the sales proceeds. However, Code Sec. 3121(b)(20) and its accompanying regulations reflected the tradition of compensating crew members with share of the profits from the sale of the catch. The history of the fishing industry, the relevant legislative history, the preamble and example contained in the regulation, and a logical and practical interpretation of the statute all indicated that "proceeds" refers to net proceeds after the subtraction of operating expenses, rather than the gross proceeds from the sale. A crew member qualifies as an employee only if the member is compensated with something other than a share of the catch, such as an hourly wage or a flat fee in excess of $100 for certain types of work.
Author Royalties
Royalty income can be subject to self-employment tax depending on the nature of the income and the taxpayer's involvement in the activities generating the royalties. Generally, royalty income is reported on Schedule E (Form 1040) and is not subject to self-employment tax. However, there are exceptions:
-
Active Participation: If the taxpayer is actively involved in the operation or management of the activity generating the royalties, such income could be considered self-employment income. This is often the case for authors, musicians, inventors, and other creators who are actively engaged in their trades or businesses and receive royalties as a direct result of their personal efforts.
-
Material Participation in a Trade or Business: If the royalties stem from the taxpayer's material participation in a trade or business, then the income may be subject to self-employment tax. This includes situations where the royalties are derived from the taxpayer's ongoing involvement in a business activity.
Income Excluded Under the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
Even if excluded, if the income is for a self-employed person, it is subject to SE tax.
Earnings Passed Through From an S Corporation to a Shareholder
This is not considered self-employment income. However, one case upheld the IRS assertion that dividends were subject to payroll taxes because the attorneys who owned the S corp. didn’t take salaries. IMPORTANT: Active shareholders need to take a “reasonable salary,” which of course, would be subject to FICA withholding. See Chapter 3.29 for more on reasonable compensation.
Statutory Employees
Income received as an employee or statutory employee is not considered self-employed income.
Taxpayer's Child Employee
A child under the age of 18, employed in their parent’s unincorporated business, is not subject to FICA/Medicare payroll taxes and is not considered self-employed for purposes of SE tax (no social security tax is owed).
A similar exemption applies for FUTA, which exempts earnings paid to a child under age 21 while employed by his or her parent.
Note that there is no FICA or FUTA exemption for employing a child if the business is incorporated or a partnership that includes nonparent partners.
Misclassified as an Independent Contractor
Where taxpayers feel they were incorrectly treated as independent contractors instead of employees and find themselves subject to a significant SE tax, they can file the Form SS-8 – “Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding” – and see if they can get a determination letter from the IRS stating they are employees. (Of course, filing the SS-8 will not make the employer very happy.)
Until a determination is made in their favor, they still have to pay the SE tax and can amend for a refund when and if they receive a favorable opinion. Once the determination letter is in hand, a taxpayer can file an amended return to add Form 8919 (and the employee’s share of the FICA taxes) and delete Schedule SE and the SE tax, resulting in a net refund equal to the employer’s share of the SE tax. Caution: The client should file the SS-8 promptly as it does not extend the statute of limitations, and should the statute expire before the determination, there is no other recourse. The client should also be aware that filing the SS-8, especially if the IRS determines employee status, could result in “burning a bridge” with that employer.
Short-Term Rentals and SE Tax
Profit from a rental activity that is reported on Schedule E is not subject to self-employment (SE) tax. But what about short-term rentals reported on Schedule C – are they subject to SE tax? Even though Pub 527, Page 12, indicates taxpayers “may” have to pay self-employment tax on short-term rental income, the “may” applies to real estate dealers. To quote Pub 334, “You are a real estate dealer if you are engaged in the business of selling real estate to customers with the purpose of making a profit from those sales. Rent you receive from real estate held for sale to customers is subject to SE tax. However, rent you receive from real estate held for speculation or investment is not subject to SE tax.” (IRC Sec 1402(a)(1))
Election Workers
Social security and Medicare taxes apply to election workers who are paid $2,400 or more in cash or an equivalent form of compensation in 2025.