Tax-Deferred Exchange Safe Harbor Rules
The IRS has four safe harbors in place for tax-deferred exchanges. Comprehensive information can be found below.
The four aforementioned safe harbors have been created to prevent the disputes about actual/constructive receipt of cash and the use of qualified agents in tax-deferred exchange transactions (Preamble to TD 8346, 04/25/91). These safe harbors ensure that an exchange qualifies for nonrecognition.
Security or Guarantee Arrangements
Taxpayers use guarantee/security arrangements in deferred exchanges to guard against a transferee’s failure to transfer like-kind property. In such arrangements, taxpayers aren’t treated as actually or constructively receiving cash or non-qualified property in an exchange when they secure the obligation of the transferee to provide replacement property with:
-
A mortgage or similar security interest.,
-
A standby letter of credit which isn’t treated as a “payment” under the instalment sale rules and which can’t be drawn on unless the obligation transferee fails to transfer the replacement property; or,
-
A third party’s guarantee.,
A security agreement that gives a taxpayer an unrestricted right to receive cash or other property does not qualify as a safe harbor.
Qualified Escrow Accounts and Trusts
Under this arrangement, a taxpayer isn’t treated as actually or constructively receiving cash or property when the obligation of the transferee is (or may be) secured by cash (or equivalent) held in a qualified escrow or trust account. The escrow accountholder cannot be the taxpayer, and the agreement must limit the taxpayer’s right to receive cash from the account (through borrowing or otherwise).
“ Example - Safe Harbor Escrow Account - Larry and Laura agree to a deferred exchange, with Larry transferring his rental property with no mortgage to Laura. The FMV of the property is $110,000 and its adjusted basis is $50,000. The agreement requires Laura to purchase a replacement rental property and transfer it to Larry. On 6/15/22, Larry transfers his rental to Laura and identifies the property he wants as a replacement. Laura pays $10,000 to Larry at that time and deposits $100,000 in an escrow account as security for her obligation to purchase the replacement rental.The escrow provides that Larry can’t have access to the escrow funds before 12/13/22 unless he:a. Doesn’t identify the replacement property within the 45-day period; orb. Identifies and receives the replacement property before the end of the 180-day period.Under these circumstances, Larry is not considered to have constructively received the funds at the time they are deposited in the escrow account. However, the $10,000, which he received from Laura in cash, is considered boot. ”
-
Qualified Intermediary
The law also provides a safe harbor when an exchange is set up using an intermediary to accomplish the transfer of property. The rules apply to both simultaneous and deferred exchanges. An unqualified intermediary can negate the exchange.
A “qualified intermediary” is one (can’t be the taxpayer or a “disqualified party”) who has a written agreement with the taxpayer, which calls for the intermediary to acquire and transfer both the property given and received in the exchange. Generally, the intermediary gets legal title to the property. A qualified intermediary can’t be the taxpayer or a party related to the taxpayer (as defined in §267(b) or §707(b), but regarding controlling interests, substitute the words “more than 10%” wherever the words “more than 50%” appear).
Bankrupt Qualified Intermediary
A taxpayer who in good faith sought to complete a Sec 1031 exchange using a Qualified Intermediary (QI), but who failed to do so because the QI defaulted on the exchange agreement and became subject to a bankruptcy or receivership proceeding does not have to recognize gain from the failed exchange until the taxable year in which the taxpayer receives a payment attributable to the relinquished property. (Rev. Proc. 2010-4)
Interest and Growth Factors
Taxpayers are often entitled to receive a growth factor (really another name for interest) on cash or property involved in a deferred exchange; the amount depends on the length of time between relinquishment of the old property and receipt of the new one. The growth factor amount must be included in income according to the taxpayer’s method of accounting. The exchange agreement must limit a taxpayer’s right to receive the growth amount.